People's History of the NHS

Back
  • 19
  • JUN

Sunny Visit to St Fagans Museum!

by Jenny Crane

On Saturday 17th June, our team made a visit to St Fagans National Museum of History to run our biggest NHS Roadshow yet.  We brought along nurses’ uniforms for people to doodle on, craft materials, objects we’ve collected sofar, public health films and posters, staff protest booklets, and a lot of surveys.  The St Fagans team displayed some brilliant objects from their archives, including a medical corset from 1946, a speculum, and their collection of prosthetics.  We set up together in the beautiful Oakdale Workmen’s Institute, and hoped that the sunny weather of the day wouldn’t lure all of our potential visitors away to the beach …

As the day went on, we were very lucky to meet many people, and our room was constantly buzzing.  Our team members had some great and detailed conversations, and we heard about experiences of childbirth, postcode lotteries, cancer treatment, work, life, and loss.  These personal, reflexive, intense encounters were invaluable to our team, helping us to better understand how people think and feel about the NHS, historically and personally.  These conversations remind us that when we write history we document something very meaningful – we are writing about people’s lives, as well as recording the entwined shifts in medical inventions, categories, and institutions.

 

Art and the NHS

In addition to having great conversations on the day, our team were also left with a variety of writings and drawings to reflect on.  The sketches on our nurses’ uniforms were particularly interesting.  Many visitors to the Museum were initially reluctant to draw on them as they sat, pristine, in the centre of our room.  As time went on, and people talked to our team, they were emboldened to write political messages: ‘No Paycap’, ‘Divided we fall and United we stand’, and ‘KEEP IT FREE’.  Some people asked our permission before writing on the uniforms, checking whether our historical project would be happy to hear ‘political messages’, whilst others shyly and quickly wrote their messages, more in the clandestine manner of graffiti.

One woman who we met had worked as a nurse in the 1970s and 80s, and told us that these were not ‘proper uniforms’ but rather ‘overalls’, because proper uniforms involve caps and capes.  This is a perception which we encounter regularly at our events, and which is informing the work of my colleague, Natalie Jones, as she plans an art piece around nursing attire.  This former nurse also told us that writing on uniforms had a long historical precedent: when she worked in the NHS, nurses’ would write reminders on the underside of their aprons.  This was a fascinating piece of knowledge which we had not encountered in the archives, but which imbues added meaning to our thinking on the everyday practices of nursing, as well as artwork with the uniforms today.

Children, also, drew for us on both nurses’ uniforms and our long sheet of paper.  Older children drew equipment which they would expect to see associated with nursing work today – scissors, pens, syringes.  Younger children, when pressed about how to ‘draw the NHS’, tended to move towards visualising helicopters and ambulances (interestingly also the most popular theme to draw at our event with child patients at University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire).  Some children’s drawings also revealed a level of commitment to, or even love for, the NHS.  We saw for example a picture of Spiderman, ‘because the NHS is a superhero’.  These images help us in our thinking about when children start to learn about the NHS.  We are also developing a picture of how children’s understandings of the NHS are formed –through exposure to news, and contact with parents, other children, teachers, and the Service itself.

 

Surveys

Following the event, we were also left with 64 filled-out surveys of various types.  Looking through these, many interesting themes emerge.  For myself, researching campaigning and activism, I was really struck by the fervency with which teenage respondents spoke about the NHS in these materials.

Another key theme, and one which we had hoped to encounter during this event, was about whether Wales and Welsh people had or have a special relationship with the NHS.  Respondents told us:

  • ‘ Don’t forget to distinguish the NHS in Wales from the NHS in the rest of the UK’
  • ‘A wonderful invention by a wonderful Welshman’
  • ‘As a Welshman, the NHS is a very emotional and proud part of our history’
  • ‘In recent years devolution has exposed differences between Welsh and English approaches towards the health service attracting criticisms from either side of the border.’
  • ‘I’ve always loved the painting of Bevan in Heath Hospital.’
  • ‘A service that Aneurin Bevan would be proud of.’
  • ‘The NHS in Wales still feels much more like a public good than in England, where outsourcing and creeping privatisation is gradually eroding the sense of the Health Service as something that belongs to the people.’

These responses, and more, help us to think about national differences in the NHS.  These differences emerge in terms of the politics of the Service, its practice and provision, and also culturally –with the figure of Nye Bevan a regular theme for our survey respondents.

Overall, our team learnt a lot from this event, and still have much to reflect on.  We are very grateful to the team at St Fagans for working on this with us, and, as ever, incredibly thankful to the people who come to our events to share their stories and reflections.  We are very privileged to hear these stories, as we try to collaboratively put together a ‘People’s History’.  Having now worked on this project for 18 months, and run over 30 events, meeting many people, our team are starting to gather a fascinating mass of information.  Our next challenge is working out how best to bring this material together, in a manner which respects and utilises the testimonies which we have collected.  We have public testimony in a variety of formats – several surveys (virtual and paper), recordings, conversations, website contributions, tweets.  These materials discuss different locations, periods of time, and life experiences.

In the months ahead, we hope to draw together a range of books, journal articles, and pieces for popular press.  These will use this range of materials, along with archival work, to reflect on how the NHS has changed over time, and what it has truly meant to people’s lives.  We very much welcome further contributions at our upcoming events, by email to NHSEngage@warwick.ac.uk, or through our website.

Upcoming Events

Exhibition: One Last Look
October 3, 2017
University Hospitals Coventry and Warwickshire

The Coventry and Warwickshire Hospital was founded in 1838, when three doctors were appointed to look after just one ward of twelve beds. In July 2006, having outgrown its site on Stoney Stanton Road, all staff and services of the
See more Events

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Twitter Feed

The information is provided by us and while we endeavour to keep the information up to date and correct, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability or availability with respect to the website or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained on the website for any purpose. We only capture and store personal information with the prior consent of users. Any personal information collected as part of the user registration process or the submission of material (including, but not limited to, name, address, e-mail address) will be stored securely on Warwick University servers, and accessible only to members of the Cultural History of the NHS project team. We will not sell, license or trade your personal information to others. We do not provide your personal information to direct marketing companies or other such organizations. These opinions do not necessarily represent those of Warwick University or the Wellcome Trust.